FishUSA Angler Resources

Top Ice Fishing Lures: Must-Have Choices for Every Species

By: FishUSA Staff

November 1, 2024

Whether you're targeting panfish, walleye, or larger predators like pike, having the right ice fishing lure is crucial for success. Below, we review some of the best ice fishing lures available, explaining how they work and why they should be in your tackle box this winter.

Whether you're targeting panfish, walleye, or larger predators like pike, having the right ice fishing lure is crucial for success. Below, we review some of the best ice fishing lures available, explaining how they work and why they should be in your tackle box this winter.

Table of Contents

  • ACME Kastmaster Lures
  • Custom Jigs & Spins Slender Spoons
  • Bay de Noc Swedish Pimples
  • Northland Forage Minnow Jig'n Spoon
  • PK Lures PK Spoons
  • Dynamic HD Ice Lures
  • Rapala Jigging Rap
  • Live Target Golden Shiner Rattlebaits
  • Salmo Chubby Darter
  • Northland Pro Angler Panfish Hardwater Kit
  • Buying Guide: How to Choose the Best Ice Fishing Lures

ACME Kastmaster Lures

The ACME Kastmaster is a versatile spoon known for its aerodynamic design, allowing it to cut through the water efficiently. Its reflective finish attracts fish by mimicking baitfish, making it suitable for a wide range of species.

The Kastmaster excels at dropping quickly and reaching the desired depth fast. I use it for everything from panfish to trout, and it shines in both shallow and deep waters. The lure’s flash and erratic action are key to triggering strikes in any water condition.

Buy ACME Kastmaster Lures

Custom Jigs & Spins Slender Spoon

The Slender Spoon by Custom Jigs & Spins offers a subtle fluttering action that mimics a dying baitfish. It’s effective for finicky fish that need a more natural presentation.

This spoon has a slow, fluttering drop that works well when fish are hesitant. I like to tip it with a small piece of bait, which increases its appeal. It’s especially effective for perch and crappie when fish are in a neutral feeding mood.

Buy Custom Jigs & Spins Slender Spoons

Bay de Noc Swedish Pimples

The Swedish Pimple is a classic ice fishing lure known for its consistent performance. Its simple design and variety of sizes and colors allows for versatile use for any species, making it a staple in many tackle boxes.

This is my go-to when I need a reliable lure that can handle various species. It’s easy to jig, and the consistent action makes it effective even on tough fishing days. It’s especially useful for perch, walleye, and even trout.

Buy Bay de Noc Swedish Pimples

Northland Forage Minnow Jig'n Spoon

The Northland Forage Minnow combines flash and a lifelike finish to mimic small baitfish. Its compact design is perfect for a wide range of species, particularly panfish and walleye.

This spoon works wonders in shallow water. Its realistic appearance and fluttering motion attract fish that are on the hunt. I often pair it with a wax worm or minnow head to enhance its effectiveness.

Buy Northland Forage Minnow Jig'n Spoon

PK Lures PK Spoons

The PK Spoon is designed for maximum flash and vibration, helping to draw fish in from a distance. It features a unique shape that creates erratic movement, triggering aggressive strikes.

This spoon’s erratic action is a game changer. I use it when I need to attract fish in murky water or when they’re scattered. The vibration and flash help to draw attention, and it’s effective on everything from panfish to larger predators.

Buy PK Lures PK Spoons

Dynamic HD Ice Lures

The Dynamic HD Ice Lure mimics a small baitfish, with a tight wobble that resembles a natural swimming motion. It’s versatile and can be used for various jigging techniques.

This lure is great for targeting finicky fish. It has a natural swimming action that doesn’t spook them, and I’ve had success with it when fish are less aggressive. It’s particularly effective in clear waters where fish are more cautious.

Buy Dynamic HD Ice Lures

Rapala Jigging Rap

The Rapala Jigging Rap is a classic glide bait that darts in wide circles, imitating a fleeing baitfish. It’s effective for aggressive species and is a must-have for ice anglers.

This is one of my favorites for triggering reaction bites. The darting motion is great for targeting walleye, trout, and perch. I use it to cover different depths and find active fish, and it rarely disappoints.

Buy Rapala Jigging Rap

Live Target Golden Shiner Rattlebaits

The Golden Shiner Rattlebait by Live Target produces a combination of sound and realistic flash, making it effective for attracting fish from a distance. Its lifelike design mimics the natural prey of many species.

This lure is perfect for aggressive jigging. The rattle draws fish in, and the lifelike appearance seals the deal. I like to use it when fish are more aggressive, and it works great for walleye and pike.

Buy Live Target Golden Shiner Rattlebaits

Salmo Chubby Darter

The Salmo Chubby Darter is a hard-bodied lure with a unique, erratic action that mimics a struggling baitfish. It’s effective for a range of species, including perch, walleye, and trout.

The Chubby Darter’s action is unlike any other. I’ve used it to catch a variety of species, and it’s particularly effective when fish are hunting. Its unique movement attracts curious fish, making it a great addition to any tackle box.

Buy Salmo Chubby Darter

Northland Pro Angler Panfish Hardwater Kit

The Northland Pro Angler Panfish Kit includes a selection of lures designed to target panfish through the ice. It’s a great all-in-one solution for those who want to have multiple options available on the ice.

This kit has everything you need for panfish. The variety allows me to switch up presentations without carrying too much gear. It’s a great starter kit for those new to ice fishing, but even experienced anglers will appreciate the selection.

Buy Northland Pro Angler Panfish Hardwater Kit

Buying Guide: How to Choose the Best Ice Fishing Lures

When selecting ice fishing lures, consider these key factors:

  • Lure Type: Different situations call for different lures. Spoons provide flash and vibration, rattlebaits attract fish with sound, and glide baits create natural darting motions. Choose based on fish activity and water clarity.
  • Action: Adjust your lure’s action depending on how fish are behaving. Aggressive jigging can trigger reaction strikes, while a more subtle presentation might coax a reluctant fish to bite.
  • Color and Size: Match the hatch by selecting colors and sizes that resemble local baitfish. Bright colors work well in murky water, while natural patterns are best for clear water.
  • Versatility: It's beneficial to carry a variety of lure types, including jigs, spoons, and rattlebaits. Being able to switch presentations helps you adapt to changing conditions and fish behaviors.

Final Thoughts

Whether you’re targeting aggressive predators or finicky panfish, having the right ice fishing lure can make all the difference. From spoons to glide baits and rattlebaits, each lure type has its unique advantages. Use this guide to find the best lures for your next ice fishing adventure and increase your chances of success on the ice this season.

Shop Ice Fishing Tackle and Gear

  • Ice Fishing Rods
  • Ice Fishing Reels
  • Ice Fishing Flashers & Sonars